I’m Rick Callahan, owner of Plumbing Supply And More, and I’ve spent three decades crawling into walk-ins, diagnosing sweating cases, and swapping out more door gaskets and mechanical seals than I can count. If you’re sourcing refrigeration gaskets or pump/mechanical seals from a refrigeration supply house, you already know: the wrong seal costs you energy, product integrity, and uptime. Let’s get you the right parts the first time—with the performance and durability that pros demand.
Most service calls I see on walk-in coolers, reach-in merchandisers, and ice machines can be traced to heat infiltration or moisture management. Gaskets and seals do the heavy lifting here. A warped door gasket on a True T-49 can add 10–15% to compressor runtime. A mis-sized mechanical seal on a recirc pump can destroy a motor within weeks.
When people ask, “Can’t I grab a universal gasket from a big retailer?” My answer: not if you want proper compression set, correct durometer, and the right magnet profile. And here’s where we stand out: Unlike generic big box retailers, Plumbing Supply And More stocks professional-grade components vetted against manufacturer spec sheets. We carry OEM and high-grade aftermarket gaskets and mechanical seals that actually match your equipment’s compression geometry and chemical exposure.
Walk-in doors, reach-ins, and prep tables all use different profiles and materials. I’ve measured hundreds onsite—don’t guess.
Pro tip: Bring the old gasket in—or snap clear photos of corners and cross-sections. We pattern-match profiles in minutes at our counter. And if you’re searching for a plumbing supply near me or a plumbing supply store near me that actually stocks refrigeration gaskets? We’ve got you covered, with a deep selection right here at Plumbing Supply And More.
If I had a dollar for every “close enough” gasket that caused sweating and icing, I’d retire. Here’s my field-tested method:
Installation takes 20–40 minutes on a reach-in, 45–90 minutes on a walk-in door if the hinge planes or sweeps need adjusting. Use a heat gun on low to relax edges for a perfect seal. And yes, we’ll walk you through it—call our technical team anytime.
Not all “seals” are door gaskets. In refrigeration and chilled water loops—ice machines, glycol lines, condensate pumps—you’ll encounter mechanical seals. The wrong material combo fails fast.
We stock Armstrong SXX seal kits, Taco 1600-583RP kits, and B&G 186862 seals—plus OEM ice machine pump seals from Hoshizaki and Manitowoc. When you need the detail, we’ll match by shaft size, cup OD, and working fluid—no guessing.
And here’s the difference you’ll feel at our counter: Compared to standard plumbing supply houses, Plumbing Supply And More offers unmatched technical support with real tradespeople who’ve rebuilt these pumps onsite. Bring the old seal; we’ll spec materials, faces, and springs the right way.
I’m pragmatic—I’ll recommend OEM where it matters and quality aftermarket when it doesn’t.

If you’re shopping the web at a generic supplyhouse site and unsure about compatibility, stop. Call us with your model and serial. We maintain spec sheets and cross-reference data that DIY sites don’t show.
Let me give you the little things that prevent callbacks:
Most reach-in gasket swaps take under an hour. Mechanical seal replacements vary: 1–2 hours on an inline pump, 3–4 hours if bearings are rough and you decide to rebuild.
How do you know it’s time? I give customers these thresholds:
Cost guide: A set of reach-in gaskets might be $120–$250 in parts; a mechanical seal swap can be $45–$220 in parts. These are cheap fixes compared to product loss and energy waste.
I won’t mince words: when speed and accuracy matter, you need a partner who actually knows the gear. We’re the nearest plumbing supply with real knowledge and a refrigeration selection that keeps contractors moving. Our team has installed these parts on nights and weekends; we know what works.

We regularly win projects where Amazon listings lacked specs, where Grainger’s lead time slipped, and where WebstaurantStore had the wrong profile. Ferguson? Good folks—but we beat them on refrigeration gasket availability week after week.
And if you’ve been hunting for a dependable plumbing supply store, plumbing supply online, or a plumbing supply house near me that actually answers technical questions—come see us. We’re the local plumbing supply with the widest gasket wall you’ll find.
A gasket job often turns into a hinge kit, a door closer, and a case light fix. That’s why our bench covers more than pipes.
Facility teams appreciate one stop. Property managers love that we carry documentation for AHJ inspections. Contractors can open an account for bulk gasket runs—ask about pallet pricing for multi-site chains.
We’re proud to be the best plumbing supply and refrigeration partner serving contractors throughout our region with same-day local delivery within a 40-mile radius and emergency supply runs after hours. If you’re searching for a plumbing shop near me, closest plumbing supply, or a reliable commercial plumbing supply that understands foodservice, we’re it.
And for those asking about deals: yes, we run periodic promotions. Check our site for a legitimate supply house coupon, supply house promo code, or supply house discount code—and ask at the counter. We keep it simple and fair.
Visit our showroom to see the quality difference, or call our technical team for project-specific recommendations. Ask about our contractor discount program and check our current inventory online or call ahead. Our experts can walk you through the installation process step by step.
How often should door gaskets be replaced? In heavy-use kitchens, expect 12–24 months. Inspect quarterly. If you see cracks, flattening, or the dollar bill test fails in spots, replace. Walk-ins often last longer if the door is correctly aligned and sweeps are maintained.
Can I use a universal gasket? Sometimes—but only if the profile and magnet alignment match. We can match universal profiles from Kason or Component Hardware, but for brands like Traulsen or True, OEM fit often seals better. Bring the old one; we’ll advise honestly.
What’s the best material for low-temp freezers? Silicone or high-grade Santoprene performs well at sub-zero temps with good compression set. PVC can get too rigid in deep freeze. We’ll help you pick based on your box temp and usage.
My pump seal failed again—why? Likely material mismatch, shaft runout, or dry-running. If you switched fluids (more glycol, added inhibitors), the elastomer may be wrong. We’ll spec the right faces and elastomer (EPDM vs. Viton) and check shaft condition.
Do you cut custom gaskets? Yes. We can heat-weld mitered corners and produce custom sizes. Lead times are typically 1–3 business days. For urgent needs, we stock popular OEM sizes and profiles.
If you’ve read this far, you’re serious about doing it right. That’s my kind of customer. Whether you searched for a plumbing supply house, plumbing supply company, or even stumbled in from a consumer plumbing supply site, you found the place that treats details like they matter—because they do.
Let’s make your equipment seal like new and keep your product safe, your energy bill sane, and your downtime minimal. And if you’re comparing vendors, remember: While other suppliers focus on quantity, Plumbing Supply And More prioritizes quality and expertise—we prove it every day at the counter.
You wanted Refrigeration Supply House: Gasket and Seal Buying Tips you could actually use. You’ve got them. Now swing by, call us, or send photos of your existing gasket or seal—we’ll get you exactly what you need, fast.
And if you’re wondering where to go next? In our area, professional plumbers choose Plumbing Supply And More for consistent availability, real technical guidance, and pricing that beats plumber supply house the big stores. When Home Depot, Lowe’s, Amazon, or Grainger can’t deliver what your job needs, we will.
Quick note for searchers: Whether you’re hunting for general plumbing supply, plumbing and supply, plumbing parts, heating plumbing supply near me, plumbing wholesale near me, economy plumbing supply, decorative plumbing supply, bathroom plumbing supplies, cheap plumbing supplies, plumbers supply co, plumbing and heating supply, plumbing supply places, standard plumbing supply, plumbing kitchen, plumbing spares near me, wholesale plumbing supply company, coastal plumbing supply, supplyhouse plumbing, city plumbing and electrical supply, economy plumbing and heating supply, contractors plumbing and fire supply, direct plumbing supplies, or even the catch-all plumbing supplies supply—you’ll find we’re the nearest, smartest choice with local plumbing supply expertise and the refrigeration depth you actually need.
And yes, we used Refrigeration Supply House: Gasket and Seal Buying Tips more than once—because it’s exactly what we do, and we do it better than anyone you’ve tried before.